Two Thousand Years of French History, All of It Apparently Your Brother’s Fault
PARIS — France is a nation that has, over the course of its history, guillotined a king, staged approximately fourteen different revolutions, and developed the concept of haute cuisine. All of these things, historians increasingly agree, were probably caused by unresolved sibling rivalry. The French do not argue about minor things. The French argue about everything with the conviction that this specific argument has profound philosophical implications and someone needs to be right, definitively, before dessert.
The Inheritance of the Apartment
The Parisian sibling rivalry reaches its highest and most dramatic form around one specific issue: the apartment. Paris apartments are small, expensive, and emotionally loaded. When a parent or grandparent leaves one to a family, the resulting dispute has the complexity of an EU trade negotiation and the emotional charge of a Greek tragedy, but with better cheese. “My grandmother left the studio in the 11th to my sister,” said Antoine Pellerin, 45, who has not spoken to his sister in three years despite living a twelve-minute Metro ride away. “It was two hundred and twenty square metres of pure injustice.” The studio, neighbours confirmed, was forty-three square metres. Antoine did not appear to be listening to this correction.
The Comparative Achievement Problem
French parents, despite the national reputation for philosophical detachment, are enthusiastic practitioners of comparative assessment. “Your sister got into Sciences Po” is a sentence that has launched more long-term psychological journeys than virtually any other in the French language. The sibling who attended the grande ecole and the sibling who “went their own way” (art school, travel, a phase involving a van) exist in permanent gravitational tension at every family gathering, orbiting a dining table laden with dishes neither of them will admit taste as good as they remember.
The Christmas Table Combustion
Christmas in Paris, according to family therapists surveyed by the entirely credible Institut Parisien des Conflits Familiaux, represents the single highest-risk period for sibling conflict in the calendar year. The tensions are specific and consistent: who brought a better wine (this will be assessed and ranked, publicly, before the first course), who called home more often during the year (this data has been compiled, silently, by the parent who claims not to keep score), and who is doing something meaningful with their life, a category defined differently by every person at the table. By the cheese course, someone has raised 1994. By the chocolates, someone has left. By midnight, there are texts. By morning, all is well. This has happened every year for thirty years. Nobody considers changing the format.
Psychiatrists note that sibling rivalry, wherever it exists globally, follows broadly similar patterns: competition for parental approval, disputes over resources, and the profound sense that the other one is inexplicably, infuriatingly, getting away with something. What makes the Parisian version distinctive is the articulacy. These arguments are conducted at a philosophical level that would be impressive in a university seminar. The grievances are marshalled with precision. The rebuttals are thorough. Someone quotes Sartre. Someone else notes pointedly that Sartre himself had complicated family relationships. The argument continues, eloquently, forever.
All the family drama, none of the travel costs, at Virtuosal.com.
